Disaster Index: 3.1 Entry: Public Consultation, Tactical Division Cause: A national broadcaster inviting the public to select the starting eleven, tactical shape, and pre-match address for Scotland's first World Cup fixture in 28 years — a function currently performed by a salaried professional. Category: Emotional / Administrative Evidence: The consultation has been opened. Respondents may field a goalkeeper. The manager has not resigned. Both conditions persist simultaneously. Historical precedent: Scotland has never suffered a measurable defeat attributable to fan-selected formations. The sample size of World Cup openers is, however, limited. Affected parties: Steve Clarke; anyone who submitted a 4-3-3 with Robertson at left back; anyone who submitted anything else. Immediate outlook: The side Clarke selects will be read against the side the public selected. The gap between those two documents will be treated as evidence. It will be filed accordingly. Filed: 12 June 2026 / Pre-Haiti baseline